This article explores the issues of violence, recognition, and freedom in the work of frederick douglass. For hegel masterslave results from the struggle for recognition. Its still valid no matter how much other people have studied and reinterpreted it. At first, being which can be an idea, individual or culture goes out into the world and discovers that there are other beings out there with opposing points of view. The master and the slave in this passage come from a familiar source, hegels phenomenology 11119, except that in here the consciousness of the. Is hegels masterslave dialectic a refutation of solipsism.
Masterslave dialectic project gutenberg selfpublishing. Hegels presentation of the master and slave in his dialectic is the most allegorical. Im also putting a link here to a pdf of umberto ecos essay on ur fascism. A second account of change is contained in the masterslave dialectic of hegels phenomenology of spirit 1807, 143152.
Studies in the hegelian dialectic11 before us of one casually selected moment after another, but obeys a definite law. Caesars legion and another dialectic, hegels master slave. Hegels master slave dialectic is a great example of the overall works logical structure of thesis, antithesis, synthesis you may have heard this about hegels work. In various different texts, deleuze distances himself from the oppositional logic at work in hegel. Radical philosophy masterslave dialectic tag archive. An introduction to the work of hegel george william friedrich hegel 17701831 is among the most important of modern political thinkers and philosophersand also one of the most difficult. Hegel by hypertext home page marxists internet archive. The reason of this is that at any point the finite category explicitly before us stands in a definite relation to the complete and absolute idea which is implicit in our consciousness. The distinctive introduction to that system, the phenomenology of spirit, which contains the famous analyses of the masterslave relation, the unhappy consciousness, and sophocles antigone, was published in 1807.
To present the key claim of this dialectic schematically. Beisers discussion of the masterslave dialectic as an argument against solipsism has two aspects, which i will treat separately. Its application in the objective basis for social life and history opens a new horizon for understanding of the historicity of human existence. Marxists not marx himself understood the reversal of the masterslave relation as one of the central messages of the book.
This chapter compares hegel and nietzsche on the topic of master and slave. We could argue this is the master slave dialectic playing out with the legion, with lanius and similar dissenters such as silas, who believes caesar is no longer the man he was and that the legion needs a stronger leader, due to caesars absence seizures and illness. At the turn of the 19th century, hegel perceived western culture as one inflicted with a pathology of implicitly contradictory dualisms which cause man to be unhappy and divided in himself. The two exceptions, both very recent, to this widespread literary neglect of the phenomenology and more specifically, the masterslave dialectic are eric sundquists and paul gilroys recent books, in which they persuasively outline the applicability of hegels masterslave dialectic to frederick douglasss situation sundquist, to wake the. Certainly one of the most famous chapters of the phenomenology of spirit is the one on lordship and bondage or master and slave knechtschaft in german is not necessarily slavery, but hegels bondsman has no rights and no contract with his master. This is a handout, developed for my students as we examine the portion of g. The slave ironically shares in the master s power because the master defines himself only in opposition to the slave.
The masterslave dialectic which occurs in hegels phenomenology of spirit represents a crucial role in his ambitious project to cure european culture. It can examine what philosophers have had to say about the nature and destiny of woman. Hegels masterslave dialectic is a great example of the overall works logical structure of thesis, antithesis, synthesis you may have heard this about hegels work. Project muse what hegels masterslave dialectic really. Towards a theory of the powerlessness of the powerful article pdf available in leadership 104. For a recent attempt to read hegels masterslave dialectic in the context of discourses of freedom in the age of colonial slavery, see susan buckmorss, hegel and haiti, critical inquiry 26 2000. It is widely considered a key element in hegels philosophical system, and has heavily influenced many subsequent philosophers. Hegels use of the masterservant relationship in the phenomenology of spirit sets the stage for the problem of recognition. The passage describes, in narrative form, the development of selfconsciousness as such in an encounter between what are thereby i.
The masterslave dialectic from the phenomenology the philosophical propadeutic hegels lecture notes, 18081811 hegels critics a collection of 60 critiques of hegel from 1841 2001 classical german philosophy. Hegels phenomenology traditionally called the masterslave dialectic. The master is the one in the interaction who succeeds. Hegels masterslave dialectic rasmus gronfeldt winther. Reading slavery through hegels masterslave dialectic pmla jj of religion in the methodist church to garner killed her youngest child to free her m whom douglass had been contracted for from a life in bondage. Hyppolite again saying that the dialectic of domination and servitude is the bestknown section of the phenomenology because of the influence it has had on the political and social philosophy of hegels successors, especially marx. But it does so from a specific point of view, namely the view of actual existing slavery. Trying to make hegel comprehensible to undergraduate students. Masterslave dialectic tag archive hegel as lord and master. Hegel begins in explaining that one only gains selfconsciousness by being engaged with an other. His major work of political philosophy, the philosophy of right 1821, is a good introduction to hegels manner of thinking. The slave ironically shares in the masters power because the master defines himself only in opposition to the slave. Certain forms of social hierarchy are intrinsically unstable. Hegel on masterslave dialectic summary one of the important and famous ideas introduced by hegel in his the phenomenology of spirit is the idea of masterslave dialectic, relationship or dynamics.
Chris arthur rp 050 autumn 1988 hegel as lord and master chris arthur introduction the feminist interrogation of philosophy can take two forms. French philosopher franz fanon, on the other hand, takes issue with the problems hegels masterslave dialectic encounters in its translation. Masterslave relationship in hegels dialectic recognition is what hegels phenomenology of mind is mainly about. Hegels phenomenology traditionally called the master slave dialectic.
By seeing the other, one recognizes that this other is different from themselves, and gives oneself identity through the. The issue at hand is selfconsciousness and the way it is formed through meeting the other. Studies in the hegelian dialectic mcmaster faculty of. Economist richard wolff draws parallels between hegels masterslave dialectic and modernday workeremployer relationship. That the masterslave dialectic can be interpreted as an internal process occurring in one person or as an external process between two or more people is a result, in part, of the fact that hegel asserts an end to the antithesis of. Binaries, dichotomies, and difference are intrinsic to the universe, to undifferentiated consciousness. The role of hegels masterslave dialectic is no exception. But such a daring reading could seduce the audience in the 1930s. The citizen is thus the synthesis of the master and the slave. Frantz fanons engagement with hegels masterslave dialectic. The slave is indispensable for the master, but the master isnt indispensable for the slave. Georg wilhelm friedrich hegels masterslave dialectic posited that most social relationships in the world were based on a masterslave model in which the master becomes as dependent on the slave as the slave is on the master.
Ironically, this is what the master wanted in the first place. French philosopher franz fanon, on the other hand, takes issue with the problems hegels master slave dialectic encounters in its translation. Her ethical theory explains and denounces extreme wrongdoing, such as the mass murder of millions of jews at the hands of the nazis. For hegel master slave results from the struggle for recognition. Hegel on the masterslave relation fifteeneightyfour. This incident, fa q a year and who cultivated a reputation as a mously retold in toni morrisons beloved. Masterslave dialectic in capitalism and what to do about. Hegels masterslave dialectic in the phenomenology of spirit. Hes opposing the thought that the only possible description of our representations are where r is a representation and t is a particular time r1t1, r2t2, r3t3, etc.
This article returns to and examines again hegels dialectic of master and slave. The chapter examines gilles deleuzes claim that hegel and nietzsche are opposites and that hegels recognition is inherently servile in nietzsches sense. Reading leadership through hegels masterslave dialectic. While he was rector of a school in nuremberg, hegel completed the. The dialectic has balanced the relations between master and slave. Thus development necessarily involves periods of conflict when the old and new ideas clash.
1177 1282 389 340 1430 1361 1104 1454 1168 318 1265 349 160 848 902 1480 1347 1475 950 815 882 1047 855 333 215 1398 333 1471 86 323 1102 1464 1471 1127 303 289 698